Why The Browns Released Baker Mayfield: The Full Story

The release of Baker Mayfield by the Cleveland Browns was one of the most talked-about NFL storylines in recent years. For Browns fans, it marked the end of an era that was filled with both hope and disappointment. For Mayfield, it was a chance to revive his career elsewhere. But why did the Browns ultimately decide to part ways with the quarterback they had once hoped would lead them to the promised land? Let's dive deep into the factors that led to this pivotal decision.

Performance Issues and Injuries

Baker Mayfield's on-field performance undoubtedly played a significant role in the Browns' decision. After being drafted as the first overall pick in 2018, Mayfield showed flashes of brilliance. His rookie season was promising, setting a then-record for most touchdown passes by a rookie. However, consistency became an issue in subsequent years. While he demonstrated the ability to make impressive throws and lead game-winning drives, he also struggled with accuracy, decision-making, and turnovers. These inconsistencies often left fans and analysts questioning if he was truly the franchise quarterback they had hoped for.

Injuries also took a toll on Mayfield's performance and availability. During the 2021 season, he played with a significant shoulder injury, which visibly affected his throwing ability. While he showed toughness by playing through the pain, his performance suffered, and the Browns' offense struggled as a result. The combination of inconsistent performance and recurring injuries raised concerns about Mayfield's long-term prospects with the team. The Browns needed a reliable and healthy quarterback to compete in the tough AFC North, and Mayfield's situation created too much uncertainty.

Furthermore, the Browns' front office and coaching staff likely evaluated Mayfield's trajectory and potential for future improvement. After four seasons, it became apparent that he might not reach the level of play required to lead the team to consistent success. This realization, coupled with the other factors, contributed to the decision to move in a different direction. It's important to remember that in the NFL, teams are constantly evaluating their players and making tough choices to improve their chances of winning. In Mayfield's case, the Browns ultimately determined that his performance, injuries, and overall trajectory did not align with their long-term goals.

Relationship with the Organization

The dynamics between Baker Mayfield and the Cleveland Browns' organization, including the coaching staff and front office, also influenced the decision to release him. While there were moments of apparent harmony, reports and behind-the-scenes accounts suggested growing friction and a breakdown in communication. These issues, though often subtle, can significantly impact a player's standing within a team and their future prospects.

One of the critical aspects of a quarterback's success is their relationship with the coaching staff, particularly the head coach and offensive coordinator. A strong, collaborative relationship ensures that the quarterback is aligned with the team's offensive philosophy and game plan. However, reports indicated that Mayfield's relationship with the Browns' coaching staff, especially towards the end of his tenure, was strained. Differences in opinion on play-calling, offensive strategy, and player development seemed to create a divide, making it difficult for Mayfield to fully execute the team's vision.

Moreover, the relationship between Mayfield and the Browns' front office, including the general manager, also played a role. A quarterback needs to have the trust and confidence of the front office, who are responsible for building the team around him. However, there were signs that the Browns' front office had begun to question Mayfield's long-term potential and leadership abilities. This lack of complete faith likely influenced their decision to explore other quarterback options, ultimately leading to Mayfield's release. It's essential in professional sports that the key players and the management are on the same page, and when that alignment falters, significant changes often follow.

The Browns' Pursuit of Deshaun Watson

The Cleveland Browns' aggressive pursuit and eventual acquisition of Deshaun Watson was the final nail in the coffin for Baker Mayfield's tenure with the team. This move sent a clear message that the Browns were ready to move on from Mayfield and pursue a different quarterback who they believed offered a higher ceiling and a better chance of winning a Super Bowl. The decision to pursue Watson was not taken lightly, as it involved significant financial investment and a considerable amount of controversy. However, the Browns' willingness to make such a bold move underscored their lack of confidence in Mayfield as their long-term quarterback.

The Browns' pursuit of Watson was driven by their desire to find a quarterback who could elevate their offense to an elite level. Watson had demonstrated exceptional talent and potential during his time with the Houston Texans, showcasing his ability to make plays with both his arm and his legs. The Browns believed that Watson's skillset and leadership qualities would make them a legitimate Super Bowl contender. They were willing to pay a premium price, including trading multiple first-round draft picks and offering Watson a fully guaranteed contract, to secure his services.

Once the Browns made it clear that they were serious about acquiring Watson, Mayfield's fate with the team was sealed. The Browns informed Mayfield's representatives that they were exploring other quarterback options, effectively signaling that his time in Cleveland was coming to an end. While the Browns initially attempted to trade Mayfield, they ultimately released him after failing to find a suitable trade partner. The Watson trade was a clear indication that the Browns were ready to embark on a new era with a different quarterback at the helm.

Baker Mayfield's Reaction and Subsequent Career

Baker Mayfield's reaction to the Browns' decision to release him was one of disappointment and a desire to prove himself elsewhere. He expressed his gratitude to the Browns' fans and the city of Cleveland but also made it clear that he felt he had more to offer as a quarterback. Mayfield quickly sought a new opportunity to revive his career and demonstrate his abilities on a different stage.

After his release, Mayfield was traded to the Carolina Panthers, where he hoped to become their starting quarterback. However, his time with the Panthers was short-lived and largely unsuccessful. He struggled to adapt to the team's offensive system and failed to produce the kind of results that the Panthers were hoping for. After a few months, he was released by the Panthers and became a free agent once again.

Mayfield then signed with the Los Angeles Rams, where he served as a backup quarterback. While he had a few moments of brilliance with the Rams, he did not get a significant opportunity to showcase his skills. His time in Los Angeles was more of a temporary stopgap than a long-term solution.

In 2023, Mayfield signed with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, where he was given the opportunity to compete for the starting quarterback job. He won the job and led the Buccaneers to a surprising division title and a playoff victory. His performance in Tampa Bay has been a positive step in rebuilding his career and reputation. Mayfield is looking to prove that he can still be a successful starting quarterback in the NFL.

Conclusion

The Cleveland Browns' decision to release Baker Mayfield was a complex one, driven by a combination of factors. Performance issues, injuries, a strained relationship with the organization, and the pursuit of Deshaun Watson all contributed to the Browns' decision to move in a different direction. While Mayfield's time in Cleveland was filled with both promise and disappointment, it ultimately came to an end as the Browns sought a new path forward. Mayfield's subsequent career has been a rollercoaster, but he continues to work hard to prove himself and revive his career. Guys, the NFL is a business, and sometimes, even first-round picks find themselves looking for a new home. It's all part of the game!