Taylor Swift Toronto Surprise Songs: The Full List
Hey Swifties! Let's dive into the ultimate breakdown of the Taylor Swift Eras Tour surprise songs Toronto that had everyone buzzing. If you were lucky enough to snag tickets for the Toronto dates, you know it was an unforgettable experience. Taylor Swift is famous for shaking things up each night with her surprise songs, and the Toronto shows were no exception. These unique performances are a special treat for fans, adding an extra layer of excitement to an already spectacular show. We're talking about songs that aren't part of the main setlist, often acoustic, and sometimes deep cuts that send the crowd into a frenzy. It’s a moment where the stadium feels like a more intimate setting, just Taylor and her guitar (or piano!), sharing a song that might have a special meaning or is just a fan favorite she rarely performs. The anticipation for these surprise songs is palpable; fans spend weeks, even months, guessing what she might play. The Toronto dates were particularly anticipated, given Canada's passionate fanbase and the sheer excitement surrounding the Eras Tour's global run. We're going to break down every single surprise song that graced the Toronto stage, giving you the full picture of what made these nights so magical. Get ready to reminisce, or maybe live vicariously through this list if you couldn't make it!
Night 1: A Fiery Start with "Would've, Could've, Should've" and "Mine"
The first night of the Taylor Swift Eras Tour in Toronto kicked off with an absolute bang, setting the bar incredibly high for the surprise songs. As the clock struck showtime and the lights dimmed, the energy in the stadium was electric. Fans were already on their feet, singing along to every word of the opening numbers, but the real magic began when Taylor graced the stage for her acoustic set. For the first surprise song, she delivered a heart-wrenching rendition of "Would've, Could've, Should've" from the Red (Taylor's Version) album. This was a HUGE moment for many fans, as it's a track known for its raw emotion and powerful storytelling. The vulnerability Taylor displayed while performing this song live was palpable, and the crowd's reaction was a mix of stunned silence and roaring applause. It’s a song that resonates deeply with a lot of people, touching on themes of regret, lost innocence, and profound reflection. Hearing it live, especially in the intimate setting of the surprise song slot, felt incredibly special. It’s a testament to the depth of her songwriting and her ability to connect with fans on such a personal level. This choice definitely catered to the fans who appreciate her more introspective and mature lyrical themes, proving that the Eras Tour is truly a celebration of her entire musical journey, from the earliest hits to the most complex narratives. The subsequent surprise song for Night 1 was "Mine" from the Speak Now album. This choice brought a completely different vibe to the acoustic set, shifting from intense introspection to a more hopeful and romantic energy. "Mine" is a beloved classic, a song that many fans associate with early Taylor Swift and her signature storytelling about love and destiny. Performing it acoustically allowed for a fresh perspective on the track, highlighting its melodic beauty and sweet lyrics. It was a perfect counterpoint to the intensity of "Would've, Could've, Should've," showcasing Taylor's versatility and her ability to evoke a wide range of emotions within a single show. The crowd sang along with every word, a sea of phone lights illuminating the stadium as they embraced the nostalgic feeling this song brought. This combination of a deeply emotional vault track and a fan-favorite classic set an incredible precedent for the surprise songs throughout the Toronto leg of the tour, leaving everyone eager to see what she would bring next.
Night 2: "Maroon" and a Surprise "Tim McGraw"
If you thought Night 1 was special, then Night 2 of the Taylor Swift Eras Tour in Toronto proved that Taylor was just getting started with the surprises! The energy was somehow even higher, if that's even possible, and the anticipation for the acoustic set was through the roof. On this particular night, Taylor stunned the audience with not one, but two incredible surprise songs that spanned her discography beautifully. First up, she treated us to "Maroon" from the Midnights album. This song, with its rich imagery and melancholic yet beautiful storytelling, really shined in its live, acoustic rendition. The deep, complex emotions woven into the lyrics about a passionate, perhaps complicated, love affair came alive under the stadium lights. Performing "Maroon" acoustically allowed the nuances of her songwriting to be front and center, highlighting the poetic quality that fans adore. It's a track that often gets praised for its mature themes and sophisticated metaphors, and hearing it performed with just her and a guitar created a moment of pure, unadulterated musical appreciation. The crowd was absolutely captivated, hanging on to every note and lyric, a testament to the song's impact and Taylor's performance. Following "Maroon," Taylor then delivered a surprise that sent shockwaves of nostalgia through the entire stadium: she performed "Tim McGraw". Yes, you read that right! The debut single from her very first album, Taylor Swift, was played live in Toronto. This was an absolutely monumental moment for long-time fans, a journey back to where it all began. It’s a song that holds so much history for both Taylor and her fanbase, representing the start of her incredible career. Seeing her perform this early hit, with all the growth and evolution she's undergone since, was incredibly emotional and powerful. The crowd erupted in cheers and sang along with unabashed joy, celebrating the entirety of her musical legacy. This surprise was a brilliant full-circle moment, connecting the very beginning of her journey with the massive phenomenon that is the Eras Tour. The combination of a sophisticated track from Midnights and the foundational hit from her debut showcased Taylor's remarkable range and the enduring appeal of her music across different eras. Night 2 was truly a masterclass in celebrating her artistry.
Night 3: "Ivy" and "All Too Well (10 Minute Version) (Sad Girl Autumn Version)"
Get ready, guys, because Night 3 of the Taylor Swift Eras Tour in Toronto was arguably the most talked-about night for surprise songs, and for good reason! Taylor decided to pull out all the stops, delivering performances that will be etched in the memories of everyone present forever. The atmosphere was already electric, but when Taylor sat down at the piano, the excitement reached fever pitch. First up, she graced the stage with "Ivy", a stunning track from the Evermore album. This song, known for its poetic lyrics and evocative imagery about a forbidden love, felt particularly poignant in its live, acoustic performance. The raw emotion and the narrative depth of "Ivy" were beautifully amplified by Taylor's delivery, making it a truly breathtaking moment. It’s a song that showcases her mature songwriting prowess, and hearing it stripped back allowed the heartbreaking beauty of the lyrics to truly resonate. The audience was visibly moved, creating an atmosphere of shared vulnerability and deep connection. It was a perfect example of how a song from one of her more 'folklore-esque' eras could captivate a stadium full of fans. But then came the moment that had everyone losing their minds: Taylor announced she would be performing "All Too Well (10 Minute Version) (Sad Girl Autumn Version)" as the second surprise song. Yes, the entire 10-minute version, complete with the raw, gut-wrenching emotion that fans have come to associate with this epic track. This was more than just a song; it was an event. The Sad Girl Autumn Version designation added an extra layer of anticipation, hinting at a potentially even more intense and emotional delivery. As she performed, the stadium was utterly silent, every single person hanging on her every word. It was a masterclass in storytelling and performance, a testament to the power of her songwriting and her ability to command an audience with sheer emotional force. This surprise song was a huge moment for the Red era, and for the Eras Tour as a whole, solidifying its status as a career-defining performance. The combination of the ethereal beauty of "Ivy" and the epic, soul-baring performance of "All Too Well (10 Minute Version)" made Night 3 an absolutely legendary night in Toronto, cementing its place in Eras Tour history.
Night 4: "Getaway Car" and "Maybe It Was All Love"
Toronto, you were truly blessed! Night 4 of the Taylor Swift Eras Tour continued the streak of unforgettable surprise songs, proving that Taylor always has something special up her sleeve for her Canadian fans. The anticipation was high, and Taylor delivered a setlist that blended fan favorites with some welcome surprises. For the first surprise song of the evening, she chose "Getaway Car" from the Reputation album. This is a song that fans have been clamoring to hear in the surprise song slot, known for its edgy vibe, intense storytelling, and explosive chorus. Hearing it live, especially in the context of the Eras Tour which celebrates the Reputation era, was a massive moment. The energy in the stadium was immense as Taylor brought her signature charisma and powerful vocals to the track. The lyrics, about a dramatic and clandestine relationship, resonated with the crowd, who sang along with passion. It felt like a perfect fit for the Reputation era celebration, offering a dose of rock-infused angst and narrative depth that fans adore. It was a high-energy performance that got everyone on their feet, showcasing the power and impact of her Reputation era tracks. For the second surprise song, Taylor surprised everyone by performing "Maybe It Was All Love" from the Lover vault tracks. This was a less expected choice, but one that was met with huge enthusiasm. "Maybe It Was All Love" is a beautiful, synth-pop-infused track that captures the dreamy, romantic, and sometimes uncertain feelings of falling in love. Its inclusion as a surprise song highlighted the diversity within the Lover album and gave fans a chance to appreciate a gem that might not have made the main setlist. The shimmering melody and Taylor's sweet delivery created a magical atmosphere, a perfect contrast to the intense energy of "Getaway Car." It was a delightful moment that celebrated the softer, more romantic side of the Lover era, reminding everyone of the infectious joy and hopeful energy associated with that album. The combination of the electrifying "Getaway Car" and the dreamy "Maybe It Was All Love" made Night 4 a truly memorable evening, showcasing Taylor's ability to deliver both high-octane anthems and tender ballads with equal brilliance.
Night 5: "The Story of Us" and "Queen of My Heart"
As the Taylor Swift Eras Tour continued its monumental run in Toronto, Night 5 was another evening filled with beloved hits and exciting surprise songs that had fans buzzing. Taylor Swift has a knack for knowing exactly what her fans want, and this night was a perfect example of that. For her first surprise song, she brought back a fan favorite from the Speak Now era: "The Story of Us". This energetic, anthemic track is known for its relatable lyrics about awkward romantic encounters and its catchy melody. Hearing it performed live, especially in an acoustic arrangement, allowed fans to connect with the song on a different level. The passion and intensity Taylor brought to the performance, even in a stripped-down version, reminded everyone of the power of her early songwriting. The crowd’s enthusiastic singalong was a testament to the enduring popularity of this Speak Now classic. It was a fantastic way to inject some high-energy nostalgia into the acoustic set. Following this beloved track, Taylor then unveiled her second surprise song: "Queen of My Heart". This was a truly special moment, as "Queen of My Heart" is a vault track from the 1989 sessions, making its live debut incredibly significant. Vault tracks are always a huge treat for fans, offering a glimpse into unreleased material that complements the beloved albums they're associated with. "Queen of My Heart" is a track brimming with confidence, self-love, and empowerment, embodying the vibrant spirit of the 1989 era. Its performance was a celebration of inner strength and self-acceptance, themes that resonate deeply with many of Taylor's fans. The infectious energy and empowering message of the song created an uplifting atmosphere in the stadium. This surprise song was a wonderful addition, highlighting the depth and richness of the 1989 vault and giving fans a taste of a track that felt destined for greatness. The combination of the energetic "The Story of Us" and the empowering debut of "Queen of My Heart" made Night 5 a standout evening in Toronto, demonstrating Taylor's incredible ability to balance fan-favorite throwbacks with exciting new discoveries.
Night 6: "Our Song" and "You're Losing Me (From The Vault)"
And just like that, the Toronto leg of the Taylor Swift Eras Tour reached its final night, Night 6, and you bet Taylor went out with a bang! The atmosphere was thick with emotion, knowing it was the last chance for surprise songs in this incredible city. Taylor, ever the show-woman, delivered a final surprise song set that was both nostalgic and deeply poignant. For the first surprise song, she decided to take us all the way back to where it all began, performing "Our Song" from her debut album, Taylor Swift. This is arguably one of her most iconic early hits, a song that embodies youthful joy, simple pleasures, and the charm of early country-Taylor. Hearing this beloved track live, especially in a stripped-down acoustic version, was a powerful full-circle moment for many. It reminded everyone of the journey Taylor has taken from her humble beginnings to becoming a global superstar. The crowd's reaction was immense, singing along to every word with a mix of nostalgia and pure adoration. It was a heartwarming way to celebrate the very first era of her career. But the surprise didn't end there. For the second and final surprise song of the Toronto run, Taylor delivered a performance that left many in tears: "You're Losing Me (From The Vault)". This track, which gained significant attention after its surprise release on the Midnights (The Late Night Edition), is known for its raw, heartbreaking lyrics exploring themes of relationship struggles and disillusionment. Performing this emotionally charged song live, especially as a surprise, was a bold and powerful choice. The vulnerability Taylor showed was immense, and the crowd was completely spellbound, sharing in the emotional weight of the song. It was a deeply resonant moment, connecting with fans who have experienced similar feelings. This surprise was a true gift, offering a cathartic experience for many and showcasing the depth of her songwriting even in her more recent work. The combination of the cheerful nostalgia of "Our Song" and the profound emotional depth of "You're Losing Me" made the final night of the Eras Tour in Toronto an unforgettable conclusion, perfectly encapsulating the vast emotional and musical landscape that the tour celebrates. It was a bittersweet farewell to a city that clearly holds a special place in her heart.
